Why We Think the Other Side Hates Us, and What Research Shows

Melissa Pavetich studies a part of polarization that rarely gets airtime: what we believe the other side thinks of us. When she joined me on High On Healthy, she called these beliefs meta-perceptions. She argued they shape hostility as much as our direct views of another group do.

Her reasoning runs in a loop. When people see a group as less than human, they tend to assume that group sees them the same way, and hostility feeds itself. Many of those assumed views are inaccurate, she said, and correcting them can interrupt the cycle. She also linked it to a quiet dynamic in groups, where “everyone’s waiting for permission, but nobody realizes they’re actually allowed to give it”.

What the research supports

A 2020 paper in PNAS by Samantha L. Moore-Berg and colleagues tested this idea with Democrats and Republicans. They found that partisans overestimated how negatively the other side viewed them, and that these exaggerated beliefs were tied to hostility. Pavetich also described a study across 11 countries. My searches did not turn up that study, so I can only point to the American work here.

The correction idea has been tested at scale. In a 2024 Science megastudy with 32,059 participants, correcting misperceptions of rival partisans’ views was among the strategies that reduced support for undemocratic practices and for partisan violence. Other approaches, such as highlighting sympathetic people with different politics, did more to reduce animosity itself.

Another way to look at it

The same megastudy adds a useful wrinkle. Treatments that cooled hostility did not always improve attitudes toward democratic norms. A UCLA Anderson summary notes that four interventions increased support for undemocratic practices, and three of those had also reduced animosity.

That does not cut against Pavetich’s point. Misperception correction was the approach that came out best on violence. It does suggest that feeling warmer toward the other side and holding firm on principles are two separate dials. I raised a version of this on the show when I asked whether we risk putting civility ahead of principle. The research suggests the answer may depend on which intervention you use.

Timing and the role of contact

Pavetich was careful about where humanizing contact fits. She said it works best when there is no active conflict and when institutions or the people involved are ready for it. She added that one bad encounter can do real damage, while a good conversation can undo a lot of it.

Her caution matches part of the broader contact literature. A review by Pettigrew and Tropp, covering 515 studies, found that contact typically reduces prejudice, and that conditions like equal status and authority support help but are not strictly required. The same review describes negative contact as typically involving people who feel threatened and did not choose the meeting.

So there are two readings, and both are useful. One says contact can help in more settings than we might assume. The other, closer to Pavetich’s, says readiness and safety deserve real attention. If you are in a tense or unsafe situation with someone, a mediator or a qualified mental health professional can help you decide what kind of conversation makes sense.

Pavetich was clear that this is not a single fix. She described it as several things that have to change before anyone actually listens. What I would like to know is how long a corrected belief holds once people go back to the feeds and headlines that shaped it.

From the episode: Overcoming Polarization Through Meta-Perceptions, with Melissa Pavetich. Read the full transcript.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top