On the show, Richard Lim made a plain case. Social media is an artificial setting where people say things they would never say in person, and he thinks that habit has followed us into how we treat family, friends and co-workers. His response is small and personal. He said “real change happens at the individual level,” and he described taking a co-worker to lunch after hearing a comment he disagreed with.
He asked the man about his view. Richard Lim still disagrees with him, but he came away seeing someone “so much more than that one little comment”.
What the research supports
Researchers have tested something close to this. In a Science Advances study by David Broockman and Erik Santoro, Democrats and Republicans were paired for a video chat. In the first experiment, they talked about a casual subject, their perfect day, and the conversations produced large reductions in polarization.
Pew Research Center adds a real-life angle. In its 2016 survey on partisan animosity, people in both parties who had few or no friends in the other party were more likely to feel very cold toward that party’s members. That is an association, not proof of cause. It does fit Richard Lim’s instinct that knowing a person changes how an opinion lands.
Another way to look at it
Richard Lim is wary of social media as a place for political talk, and there is research that fits his caution. In a field experiment led by Christopher Bail, Democrats and Republicans were paid to follow Twitter bots that shared views from the other side.
Republican participants expressed substantially more conservative views after following a liberal bot. Democrats shifted slightly in a liberal direction after following a conservative bot, though that change was not statistically significant.
One reading is that the setting matters a great deal. Seeing opposing views in a feed, from strangers and at a distance, may work very differently from sitting across a table. Bail’s team was exposing people to messages. Richard Lim was proposing a conversation with someone he already knew.
What researchers are still exploring
The Broockman and Santoro work also raises a question about the lunch itself. Their paper argues that cross-party conversations can reduce hostility, but that the effect is especially likely when topics avoid areas of disagreement. They also expect it to fade over time and to leave views on democratic accountability unchanged.
In their second experiment, pairs discussed tense subjects, such as what they disliked about each other’s party. The headline of the university-linked summary says those brief talks had little power to narrow divisions.
Richard Lim’s lunch question went straight to a point of disagreement, so on this reading it is a harder case than a chat about a perfect day. He also described a habit that may make it easier. At the office, he asks people about their evening and their family before anything else. That kind of ordinary opening looks a lot like the shared-topic conversations in the study.
These are short experiments with strangers, and a workplace lunch between two people who see each other every week is a different situation. Whether a conversation that starts with family and moves to the disagreement holds the warmth longer is something I could not find tested directly.
From the episode: Navigating Political Polarization and Historical Parallels, with Richard Lim. Read the full transcript.
