Who Owns Your Attention? Gloria Mark on Rethinking Focus in the Digital Age

High on Healthy · Listen
0:00 / --:--

In this episode of High on Healthy, host Richard Zwicky speaks with Gloria Mark, professor of informatics at UC Irvine, about how digital technology and AI impact human attention spans, critical thinking, and social well-being.

Mark explains that while our fundamental capacity for focus remains intact, modern environments foster constant interruptions—both external and self-induced—that fragment our focus and drive up stress.

She stresses the importance of reclaiming our agency, establishing organizational guardrails, and viewing AI as a guiding tool rather than a replacement for human thought.

Key takeaways

  • We have not lost our capacity for attention, but our digital environment makes it harder to use.
  • People interrupt themselves out of habit, and when outside interruptions drop, self-interruptions rise.
  • Attention residue means thoughts from an interruption carry forward and interfere with the task you return to.
  • Interruptions that relate to your current work tend to feel helpful, while unrelated ones feel harmful.
  • Treat AI as a tutor or a critic after you have done your own work, not as a replacement for your thinking.

The big idea: Why Is It So Hard to Focus? Habit, Not a Broken Brain

More conversations on Attention and Focus, AI, Technology and Mental Health, Loneliness and Connection

Read the full transcript

Richard Zwicky: Hi everyone, I'm Richard Zwicky, your host for High on Healthy, the show where we know there's no one path to healthy, so we explore them all. People often comment about attention and technology and saying how technology just cause them to divert their attention all the time. But does technology really reshape the way we think?

Gloria Mark: Thanks for having me.

Richard Zwicky: And that becomes a question of who owns your attention? And that's what we're going to talk about today with Gloria Mark who is a professor of informatics at UC Irvine. Welcome aboard the show, Gloria. So, my opening statement really goes to the heart of something people are always commenting on. I have ADHD, but people joke about, I have ADHD. I'm bouncing from one thing to the next all the time. My attention span is getting shorter. You spent years actually measuring what people do with technology. Are we losing our attention or are we living inside an environment that has learned how to take advantage of it? Right.

Gloria Mark: So it's the latter. We're not losing our capacity for attention, we still have the same attentional mechanisms that we've always had. It's that our environment has changed. So it's more of a challenge. It's harder for us to pay attention and there's a lot of reasons for that. Imagine we'll get into it. But yeah, we struggle to pay attention in this digital age.

Richard Zwicky: We do and a lot of times when we're dealing with children or with co-workers and who are struggling with distraction we treat it as a failure of discipline. We look at is why can you not just pay attention? Why can you know but is the difficulty of sustaining attention a rational response to an environment that is really more and more designed around interrupting it at us at every moment.

Gloria Mark: I mean I think what we're doing it is the natural response to the environment. You're right. We live in a world where we're interrupted by texting, by email. I mean there are many external sources of interruptions. But we also interrupt ourselves. And so the way I would explain that is if I were observing a person and let's say they were working on a word document, they suddenly stop what they're doing and they switch to email or they switch to social media or they switch to news. So this is an interruption from something internal in them and that comes from habit. People have developed habits to switch their attention. We've always interrupted ourselves, right? This is not new. But what is new is that there are many more opportunities for us to become habituated to interrupting ourselves.

Richard Zwicky: I built one of the first search analytics platforms and originally we looked at things in people's attention spans and we noted that if people were watching a video, they'd phase out at 2 minutes and 42 seconds. And as we were preparing presentations, we knew that we had to interject some sort of exclamation or some sort of interrupter every 2 minutes or so in a 10-minute presentation. Something that caused people to stop and think differently than just listening. But the analytics tools today show us that the amount of time people are staying anywhere before switching is getting shorter and shorter. And some of it is the training from things like Tik Tok and everything else. But the measurement, is reflecting the data. But What does it capture that's meaningful from your perspective about those changes? Is the dwell time or is it we're able to focus in faster, absorb the information faster, and move ahead?

Gloria Mark: We don't know if we're able to capture essentially the essence of what we're looking at faster. What we know is that people are having a harder time to sustain attention for a period of time on one thing. So we first started measuring attention objectively on screens. This was back in 2004 and we found a statistic very similar to what you found.

00:05:00

Gloria Mark: We found about two and a half minutes that people stayed on a screen before switching to something else. But over the years, we find that the time for sustained attention on any screen became shorter and shorter and starting around 2016 or so, it began to average 47 seconds. And this is from multiple studies, not just a single study. Yes, so the ability to sustain attention has gotten shorter. I shouldn't say ability because we still have that ability. We haven't lost that ability. It's just that our practices have changed so that our practice is to spend a shorter amount of time on anything on screen.

Richard Zwicky: And what separates those interruptions from the ones we generate ourselves in terms of how our minds shift and focus differently?

Gloria Mark: So when an interruption comes from outside of us, very often it's automatic. In other words, we see a flashing notification. We hear a ping we just automatically respond to it. And that is a kind of attention that's not conscious, right? It's more of a reactive response. But what's when interruptions come within us, This is usually from habit, you have a thought that comes into your head and you immediately want to search for it to find the answer or you might see some cue from something you read you're hearing something. This reminds you of something and so you immediately want to look it up or go to a social media site or check your email. So there are a number of things that originate from inside of us that cause us to self-interrupt and we become habituated. So in fact we did do a study where we looked at external interruptions in relation to internal interruptions and we found that when the number of external interruptions went down in any hour what happened is the frequency of internal interruptions went up and the way I interpret is that people are just determined to be interrupted. So they're habituated. They're so used to being interrupted every so often. We found an average of 47 seconds. Sometimes it's longer, sometimes shorter. But if you're not being interrupted from something outside of yourself, then your habit kicks in for you to self-interrupt. And so that's what we found.

Richard Zwicky: So, back years ago with my first analytics company, one of my developers did was he was interested to see how his workflow changed during the day, his speed of coding, and how often he was finishing pieces. And one of the piece of data that he came across and looked at was he tracked interruptions from his own perspective and when he was focused in coding and what happened when he was interrupted, somebody came to him with question, there was something that happened. He turned off, his messages, everything during the day as he was working but people would still come to him and say, "Hey, you know what about this?" And he noticed that it took him 45 minutes to get back up to speed after an interruption. That was really interesting. That's a long time for some, but is that normal?

Gloria Mark: Is that normal? There are individual differences, right? Some people take longer,

Richard Zwicky: I mean, there's no normal.

Gloria Mark: Some there is that's right.

Richard Zwicky: Yours is the only normal,

Gloria Mark: There is something called attention residue which is that when we're interrupted we deal with the interruption and that stays in our mind right and it interferes with our current task of hand right so whatever we were thinking about during that last interruption stays with us right it carries forward and

00:10:00

Gloria Mark: It interferes with the current thing that we're trying to focus time. So that's why, I don't know what it was that interrupted this person that took him 45 minutes to get back on task, but there and it might not have been just that thing he was thinking about, but it could have opened up a whole chain of different kinds of thoughts, which made it hard for him to get back on track.

Richard Zwicky: It's hard to control our own minds, isn't it? And that leads me to the point where often we get an idea in our head and it's just niggling back there and it pops up. And those aren't interruptions that somebody else created. They're their own internal interruptions. Do we handle those differently?

Gloria Mark: I mean, it's hard to say because it's internal, right? It's inside people's minds and some people are able to suppress those thoughts and other people act on them. I mean from my perspective we have the ability to satisfy curiosity at our fingertips. So if something comes to mind some question could even be a very silly question. I have silly questions all the time. You can immediately within seconds even milliseconds find out the answer and it satisfies our curiosity.

Richard Zwicky: And in a way that's our nervous system asking for a break and a distraction also.

Gloria Mark: It's natural for people to mind wander, right? And if you're just taking a walk and you don't have any media, your mind is probably going to switch back and forth from the environment around you to your internal thoughts. And you're sitting on a park bench, you're probably going to be lost in your thoughts. You're going to mind wander. And that's very common. People mind ponder a large percentage of the day.

Richard Zwicky: They do. And when I go hiking for often five to sometimes eight hours on weekends. And I love the piece. I'm going to have conversations with whoever I'm with, but then we also go for an hour or two at a time where we don't say anything. And the mind's wandering, but it's really clearing out and allowing me to think about things that I haven't thought of for a while or brings ideas forward, which I sometimes interrupt. I pull out my phone and I make notes because I don't want to forget it in that moment. That's also something which people wake up in the middle of the night with an idea and they go, I'll think about that and get back to in the morning and most often they roll over and forget about it by the morning, right?

Gloria Mark: Forget Yeah, it's a great question.

Richard Zwicky: Those are interruptions as well. How do we decide how do we learn which to pay attention to which not to

Gloria Mark: So interruptions can be disruptive, but they can also be beneficial. And we actually studied this at one point and we found in the workplace that when people were interrupted with some kind of question that related to their work then they found it to be beneficial because it helped them think about their work in a different way. Or else they felt really good to be helping a colleague who they might have been collaborating with on the same project. So ultimately they viewed it as helpful but when interruptions were on a completely different topic then people just found it disruptive and it was harmful to their work. So yeah, I would say that when interruptions relate to your task at hand, they're beneficial. But having said that sometimes we come up with completely different ideas for some other task and that can be very helpful.

Richard Zwicky: It's how I've written patents that way by taking the notes of the interruption.

Gloria Mark: I mean it could be right.

Richard Zwicky: But there's differences between clearing one's mind and allowing the freedom to spend the time thinking about those things and having the interruptions which you mentioned the interruptions at work and the distractions and the lack the focus but are we tuning our brains that socially we're also looking for the interruptions and it's affecting how we socialize with others

00:15:00

Gloria Mark: People we are social beings. We need to interact with other people and there are some theories that we interrupt so to satisfy a social need and that could very well be the case. I think that it's problematic when those interruptions become too frequent and they interfere with our ability to do work. What's better is to take a longer social break where you really have time to interact with another person, And then you get more fulfillment that way as opposed to some, quick break where you might chat with someone for less than a minute and then go back to work. It's much better to take a longer break and that I think the social need would be more deeply satisfied if you did that.

Richard Zwicky: And I was reading a study just the other day about the change in people's behavior around socializing and two blocks. The period leading from the early 2000s to the pandemic and then pandemic on and socializing where people would get together regularly with friends had dropped by 70%. And dinners and where you create that regular social pattern and then since the amount of time individuals spend at home and alone has gone up by over 70% as well. How did I mean all of that changes how we're interacting with people and our technology is changing how we connect with others because I mean technology also allows us to connect with communities around the world. But does this create a different form of stress that amplifies how we interact as a whole? And does it create a societal issue where our social feedback loop is lacking?

Gloria Mark: I do think we're heading into a pretty serious problem here because loneliness is rising as you point out,

Richard Zwicky: It amplifies stress, right?

Gloria Mark: Our social connection is decreasing and technology is amplifying those tendencies. For examp and it amplifies stress, right? Because we have more information to deal with when we're interrupt. Interrupted. It's stressful to try to get back on track. And of course, many interruptions through communication benefit the sender and not the receiver. So, if I'm getting email from someone or text messaging or Slack, it's because someone wants something from me. They want information. They want me to solve a problem. And so the person the receiver is getting inundated with all these requests to do things for other people. I mean it's good we want to be colleial. We want to be social but we also have to think about preserving our own attention and well-being.

Richard Zwicky: And we've also got to the point where we think being alone on some not alone but not having something to do with the interruption means we're bored, right? Yeah.

Gloria Mark: We have forgotten how to be bored and we have forgotten that boredom can bring benefits. So, there was a study done that showed that when people are bored, they generally turn to social media and then what happens is they get even more bored. So, there's this feedback loop, right? You're bored, you go to social media, you become even more bored, go back to social media. So we've created this environment where we just can't sit with boredom. But boredom can have advantages, Boredom is a signal that we need to find things to do that have meaning for us. And so it's not bad to sit with boredom because it's an opportunity to be able to think about doing something else that's more purposeful.

00:20:00

Richard Zwicky: It's an opportunity to take the time for oneself, To open a book, to watch a movie if that's what you want. It's to just draw, to paint, to do anything that gives you I mean watching movies a very passive thing. The others are more active. You're painting, you're sculpting, you're writing something. You're putting yourself into a situation where you're creating. And that creativity is something we all need to encourage because that's what drives innovation and growth. Yeah.

Gloria Mark: Or having a conversation with another person. When you're bored, pick up the phone and call someone or go out and be with other people.

Richard Zwicky: Don't say that. Everybody's going to think I'm bored all the time because I always talk to people.

Gloria Mark: I'm No not necessarily. It's showing that you're doing something that's more meaningful for you.

Richard Zwicky: I'm sorry I'm being flippant,

Gloria Mark: It's not showing that you're bored. It's showing that you're intentionally interested in people. And of course, there's nothing wrong with just sitting with boredom and just letting your mind wander. No.

Richard Zwicky: There's times where it's just nice to sit and think. It's incredibly powerful. But the economy isn't driven around that. It's really driven around how do we get somebody's attention? How do we monetize that? And how do we get them to believe something is worth paying attention But the deeper effect is it changes people's values or

Gloria Mark: Can you say more about that?

Richard Zwicky: More what they value. So if you're constantly getting the information through that reinforces or you fat an interest in a particular topic it starts the systems will feed you more and more information about that topic. You'll see more of the influencers who are showing you their perspective on the best way to live it or the best way to do it is and are people's value shift to not what developing their own but developing based on other people's beliefs and systems because it's a follow the leader right and it's a bit Yeah, right.

Gloria Mark: It could work that way if people are very susceptible to influencers, but people also spend a lot of time gaming online. That's a big one. Or they spend a lot of time watching films and watching TV. So pe people can potentially be influenced by a number of different sources. And yes, they can also be influenced by influencers as well or by other people who they're texting. So it's yes I mean certainly people have the potential to be influenced by other people online. I think the issue is that they have the potential to be in influenced by people who they don't know who may be people who are relaying news that may not have the credentials to vet news properly as opposed to conversing with friends. We can be influenced by our friends, but we know them, we know we choose them and

Richard Zwicky: We choose them.

Gloria Mark: We know the characters and backgrounds of our friends. And so that's a different kind of influence. So the problem with the internet is that we can be influenced by so many different sources and we don't actually know how reputable these individuals are. So there is a danger there.

Richard Zwicky: And AI of course brings a whole new layer and phase to the attention challenge because before we had to actively go and search for information and refine our searches and dig into things at least. Now we can give one or two sentence that explains here's the area and it spits out information back at us and it's getting better in terms of there's less hallucinations and there's less creativity in the responses from the perspective of facts are no longer being created as often the systems are getting better from that.

00:25:00

Richard Zwicky: But the systems learn to anticipate what you want and can keep a conversation going forever and take you down rabbit holes and constantly reinforcing you're so smart. You're good to have pointed this out when you point out a different thing. That conversation only doesn't ever end but it changes how people focus and their attention but how they understand themselves. How do we help shift that so that people retain agency without realizing how it's slowly being eaten away? Right.

Gloria Mark: It's a great question. So there are studies coming out that show that people are losing their ability to think critically and there are very good studies that are showing that the more people rely on AI for information the more they trust it and the weaker their own thinking skills So this is a very real danger. What do we do about it? The problem is that a AI has infiltrated everything. It's infiltrated the workplace. It's infiltrated schools. It's infiltrated homes. So we need to be before it gets too late, we need to rethink our relationship with So rather than having it do the work for us, we have to think of AI rather as a guide. I just read a study that showed that when AI works as a tutor, encouraging students to think on their own. They actually perform pretty well. Some people use AI as a critic. So, you write it on your own. You put in the effort, you put in the work, and then the AI critiques what you've written. This is what we academics have done forever, right? You get peer reviews. You get critics of your work and then you can refine it or choose not to. And that's the same with AI. You don't have to revise your work based on what AI tells you to. You have to think for yourself. So we have to understand that it's just one other perspective on what we're doing.

Richard Zwicky: And it is and on September 29th there was the announcement out of Washington at the White House where many of the senior leaders in AI gathered and there was a hoopla about creating a statement of ethics which was voluntary and not everybody has to agree with and doesn't have to honor all the time and it really is nobody knows what to do and they're just whitewashing to say we're going to do something but we don't know what it is and Maybe we'll honor and maybe not. It was when the details, it kind of doesn't look very good. But where does the responsibility sit? Is it with the individual? Is it how we teach people to use it? Or is it with platforms who are trying to grab our attention? And have we created a system where we're our own worst enemy? Right?

Gloria Mark: So my own sense is if we're waiting for tech companies to do something, we're probably going to have to wait for a long time and we might also be waiting for a long time if we're waiting on government to enact policy. So I think we need to think about change at the organizational level. The work organization, schools, we need guard rails. We need better for schools. We need literacy programs that teach students. Here's what AI can do for us and here's what we can do for ourselves where we shouldn't let get involved. Now a lot of schools have guard rails on AI use during the school day. The problem is when students go home there are no guard rails and so they're using it. I'm very worried about students using AI with school work, having it do the work for them. Because young people are in this very critical developmental stage where they're learning how to think and if AI is taking that away from them, what are we producing for this next generation? So, we have to retain that ability for young people to be able to think for themselves and

00:30:00

Richard Zwicky: Isn't that I understand what you're saying, but isn't it really the challenge is they will use What we need to do is figure out how to teach them how to think critically when using AI.

Gloria Mark: That's right. That's why I'm a big advocate for literacy programs media literacy programs in schools that can teach young people to be aware of what AI can do, what it should do and not. So I think it's extremely important, but we also have to educate parents. So you ask where does their responsibility lie? So if we're talking about young people it lies s, on parents to model correct behavior and on the students themselves that we educate them so that they understand what should be most important for them is developing their own minds. In the workplace, that becomes very complicated because AI has sped up the pace of work and so no individual wants to suddenly stop using AI because others will speed by them. So there really needs to be an understanding at the organizational level of here's what AI should do here's what it should not be used for. I mean my other worry and this is like on a societal level is that with AI we produce flawless output right now of course putting hallucinations aside

Richard Zwicky: It's perfectly imperfect.

Gloria Mark: But as you point out it's getting better and better but what's happening also is we're getting used to flawless output such that when humans make mistakes we're not going to tolerate that. So, imagine getting a love letter from someone and it's written by AI and it's perfect. There are no mistakes, but at the same time, there's also no humanness in it. And so,

Richard Zwicky: And that's where time together is so important And that goes back to the earlier question about isolation. Glory we are out of time for today, but people want to learn more about your work and the topics. How can they learn more? Yep.

Gloria Mark: So, I have a book that's called Attention Span, which covers a lot of what we've talked about today. I write a Substack that's called The Future of Attention, which als it's free and it covers what we talked about. And I have another book coming out next year that's called the lost art of thinking for ourselves, thinking for yourself. And that also covers AI and it also covers your very first question that we've created this digital environment that's affecting not just how we pay attention but it's affecting how we remember we think how we relate to other people our sense of purpose our stress. So it affects us in so many ways. Yes. So,

Richard Zwicky: And the lost art of thinking is a powerful topic. Very pertinent.

Gloria Mark: Pay attention. It'll come out probably next spring.

Richard Zwicky: I look forward to that. Thank you so much for joining us on High on Healthy. Gloria And thanks to everybody for listening.

Gloria Mark: It was my pleasure.

Richard Zwicky: I'm Richard Zwicky and we'll be back again with you soon.

This transcript was generated automatically and lightly edited for readability.

Scroll to Top