A chatbot can help with many questions. A moment when suicide risk is emerging is not one of them. That is the view of Christine Moutier, a psychiatrist and the chief medical officer of the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention. She joined me on High on Healthy to talk about what happens when someone in crisis turns to a machine.
Why the match matters
Moutier points out that most people use AI the way they use a search tool. They ask about school, work, an argument, or a habit they want to change. That is ordinary use. Her concern is the moment when stress starts to change sleep, mood, and thinking, and a person needs more than self-care.
She says the signs are things anyone can learn to hear. A person may sound overwhelmed. They may feel like a burden. They may feel trapped. These signs matter more after a rejection, a legal problem, or a financial crisis. In those moments she would rather people reach a trained counselor through 988, by call or chat. Counselors are there to help someone move from a hot moment to a calmer one.
She also explains why a chatbot can miss what is happening. Under acute stress, the thinking brain can narrow its options, a kind of tunnel vision. A person in that state often does not describe it in clear language. They may use metaphor. Moutier described a tragic case where a person talked about going home and the platform did not recognize what that meant.
Warning signs in the chat itself
Moutier notes that the reported cases share a pattern. The conversations were enormously long and very frequent. She suggests treating constant, flattering feedback with skepticism, whether it happens to you or to someone you love. She also names a clear danger signal: a bot that encourages secrecy and tells someone not to talk with parents, teachers, or others in their life.
She does not claim the answer is to keep people away from AI. People will keep using it. She hopes the tools can be trained on the listening methods that crisis lines already use, and that they never provide detailed information about lethal means.
Her closing advice is simple. Be curious and caring without judgment. You do not need to be anyone’s therapist. As she put it, “Don’t underestimate the power that you have in other people’s lives.”
Here is one thing to try. Think of one person in your life who seems to be struggling. Ask how they are doing, then listen without trying to fix anything. If you are worried about their safety, point them to 988 in the United States.
From the episode: When Crisis Meets Code: Navigating AI and Suicide Prevention, with Christine Moutier. Read the full transcript.
